In a significant development in the solar energy landscape, Tongwei Co., Ltd. announced on the evening of February 14 that it is halting its prospective investment in Jiangsu Runyang New Energy Technology Co., Ltd., commonly referred to as RunyangJust a few months prior, on August 14, 2024, Tongwei had expressed intentions to acquire a minimum of 51% of Runyang’s equity for a total amount not exceeding 5 billion yuan, subsequently positioning Runyang as a subsidiary under its control, which would have marked a pivotal expansion in Tongwei’s production capabilities.

Following the signing of the strategic agreement, Tongwei spearheaded a series of comprehensive audits, assessments, and legal analyses concerning Runyang's operationsMultiple rounds of extensive negotiations were conducted, with the common goal being the long-term sustainable growth of Runyang and its stakeholdersHowever, as of the announcement, several critical business terms remained unresolved, prompting Tongwei to withdraw from the acquisition discussion.

Despite this setback, both companies are still considering potential collaborations focused on polysilicon business operationsTongwei intends to extend its professional technical and management support to improve operational efficiencies within Runyang's projects and enhance its competitiveness in the polysilicon sectorIf initial cooperative ventures yield fruitful outcomes, there remains a pathway for deeper engagements between the two entities in the future.

A solar energy investor highlighted the industry's pressing issue of overproduction, noting that acquiring outdated or redundant capacities offers no strategic advantage unless a company is unable to develop its capabilities within a short timeframeThis sentiment reflects the broader market challenges and signifies a critical juncture for companies plotting their strategic trajectories in the polysilicon and solar panel manufacturing arenas.

Evaluating the financial implications, if Tongwei had proceeded with the acquisition, its investment of 5 billion yuan would have unlocked substantial industrial silicon capacities, including 55,000 tons of industrial silicon, 130,000 tons of solar cells, 7 GW of pulling capacity, and expansive capabilities for cutting and battery production

Advertisements

This acquisition would have significantly bolstered Tongwei’s standing in the market.

Without the acquisition, however, Tongwei's existing capacities will continue to expand, estimating a reach of about 980,000 tons of polysilicon and 157 GW of solar cell production, solidifying its status as a leader in the industry while securing the fifth position in module production capabilities.

In recent years, Tongwei has undertaken aggressive capacity expansionsIn April 2022, the company set ambitious targets to elevate its polysilicon capacity to between 800,000 and 1 million tons and its solar cell production to between 130 GW and 150 GW by 2024-2026. At that time, Tongwei had a relatively modest production of 180,000 tons of polysilicon and 45 GW of solar cells, revealing significant growth potential, particularly as it began ramping up its module manufacturing operations.

However, the landscape is not without challengesIn the wake of substantial industry losses last year, the pressure from expanded capacities has begun to strain Tongwei's financial healthThe company reported a stark decline in its financial performance in its third-quarter report for 2024, with revenues plummeting approximately 38.73% year-over-year to 68.3 billion yuanAdditionally, Tongwei posted a net loss nearing 4 billion yuan, a striking contrast from its previous profits of 136.13 billion yuan.

The financial ratios suggest growing concern; Tongwei’s debt-to-asset ratio rose from about 55% at the end of 2023 to approximately 67% by mid-2024, primarily driven by the increased cost of new project investments and necessary liquidity maintenance for day-to-day operations.

Runyang's financial metrics similarly reflect pressuresAs revealed in its mid-2023 prospectus, Runyang reported total assets of around 21.6 billion yuan against liabilities of about 17.1 billion yuan, translating to a concerning 79% debt-to-asset ratio, highlighting the precarious nature of financial health within the sector.

Looking ahead, projections for 2024 indicate that Tongwei anticipates losses in the range of 7 to 7.5 billion yuan due to significant price declines across the industry and an anticipated write-off of nearly 1 billion yuan in long-term asset impairments

Advertisements

This downturn is consequential, reflecting a broader trend toward more advanced and efficient technologies like TopCon, which has rapidly gained market share.

Investors are keenly evaluating whether Tongwei's efforts to acquire Runyang would exacerbate its financial burdens or perhaps provide synergistic opportunities that help bolster its market positionTangibly, as of the end of the third quarter of 2024, Tongwei has around 31 billion yuan in cash reserves, with limited constraints on these funds primarily due to various deposit requirementsThis liquidity offers some reassurance regarding future operational capabilities and strategic investments.

With a commitment towards consolidating its existing capacities and operational efficiencies, Tongwei has no major project launch plans beyond the completion of its Baotou silicon project in the near termInstead, anticipated capital expenditures for 2025 appear to focus on payments related to existing projects, indicating a strategic pivot towards stabilization amidst turbulent market conditions.

From the information shared in the recent announcements, it is evident that Tongwei still recognizes the value of Runyang's polysilicon operations, although the proposed acquisition did not encompass Runyang's battery production capabilitiesThe current solar market remains highly competitive and rapidly evolving, with investor interest gravitating towards entities that can efficiently transition production lines in response to changing technologies and market dynamics.

A market analyst remarked that in light of the accelerated pace of technological advancements and increasing competition within the battery sector, companies like Runyang must adapt or risk being sidelinedRunyang's production capabilities currently hinge heavily on its older PERC technology, which previously dominated solar markets but is now rapidly giving way to more efficient solutions such as TOPCon and HJT.

This technology shift necessitates costly upgrades to Runyang's manufacturing processes, especially given that a significant portion of their production capacity relies on PERC technology — accounting for over 95% of their production — while new initiatives focus on incorporating TOPCon technology

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements